Artsakh: a sober political assessment. Ashot Harutyunyan

  • by Editbeglari, September 22, 2025 in News
269 views

 These days,  many statements are circulating that the people of Artsakh can restore their independence. Such claims, no matter how emotional and desirable they may seem, have no political or legal basis due to the denialist policy of the Prime Minister of the Republic of Armenia, Nikol Pashinyan.

The independence of Artsakh has never been recognized by any state, not even by the Republic of Armenia. It remained an unrecognized entity without international subjectivity from 1991 to 2023. Moreover, after the Azerbaijani, aggression in September 2023, the last representative of the Artsakh government.  Acting President Samvel Shahramanyan, signed a document of self-dissolution. In other words, within the self-proclaimed independence, the official body announced the This sad reality means that the platform on which the idea of ​​Artsakh statehood was built has itself collapsed. Therefore, talk of “gaining independence” is not only unrealistic, but also a dangerous delusion that will once again serve the interests of external Armenian-destroying forces.

A sober assessment of international experience is needed here. History has repeatedly shown that if any structure does not have international recognition and a solid legal basis, then its existence is temporary.

The example of Northern Cyprus shows that even the support of a powerful military patron (Turkey) is not enough for international recognition. The UN Security Council, back in 1983, in its resolution 541, recorded that the proclamation of the “Turkish Republic” in Cyprus has no legal force.

Abkhazia and South Ossetia, despite Russia’s “recognition,” continue to be considered integral parts of Georgia. The UN General Assembly expressed the same position in its resolution 62/249 (2008).

Taiwan, with its economically developed system and international cooperation, has no place in the UN, since international law considers it part of China.

The case of Kosovo is the most successful “separatist” attempt in international terms, but it has not received universal recognition either. Moreover, the UN International Court of Justice, having recorded in 2010 that Kosovo’s declaration of independence did not violate international law, did not compel its recognition. In other words, the issue of legal recognition remains within the realm of political decisions.

These examples clearly show that the declaration of independence in itself is not enough: without a solid foundation in international law and broad recognition, such entities remain temporary and vulnerable.

In the case of Artsakh, the issue was never about “independence”. During the Soviet Union, Artsakh was administratively annexed to Azerbaijan as the Nagorno-Karabakh Autonomous Oblast, without emphasizing its Armenian identity. This was an occupation of the territory of the Armenian people, and this occupation never received international legitimacy. Therefore, there can be no question of “independence” here, since independence can only be achieved from a legally existing state. Neither the Musavat nor the ASR enjoyed international recognition. The issue of Artsakh has always been liberation from Azerbaijani occupation and reunification.

A decisive legal step in this direction was taken on December 1, 1989, when the Supreme Council of the Armenian SSR and the National Council of the Nagorno-Karabakh Autonomous Region adopted a joint decision on the reunification of Armenia and Artsakh. This was not only a political declaration, but also a legal fact, which clearly showed that starting from December 1, 1989, Artsakh cannot be considered a territory occupied by Azerbaijan.

Today, when even Russia does not officially refer to the illegal decision of the Council of Ministers of 1921, the Armenians of Artsakh are left to rely on the documents of international law, the Treaty of Sevres, which are still in force. The Treaty of Sevres clearly enshrines the rights of the Armenian people to their Homeland. The Treaty of Sevres has never been canceled by a document with the force of international law and continues to remain the legal basis for the national-state demands of the Armenians.

In this context, the Republic of Western Armenia, which considers Artsakh to be its indivisible state, rightly rejects any idea of ​​“independence” – in fact, any idea of ​​separatism. The future path of Artsakh, enshrined in international law, is liberation from the Azerbaijani invaders and reunification with the united Homeland of the Armenian people.

Therefore, the future of Artsakh depends not on desirable rhetoric, but on the effective application of historical facts and the power of international law.